Suga is set for a busy year. The BTS rapper added new dates to his upcoming world tour. The news comes right after Agust D confirmed the release of his first solo album ‘D-Day.’
SUGA Agust D Tour Adds 2 More Dates in Asia
The official BIG HIT Entertainment Twitter account confirmed that two new dates have been added to the SUGA Agust D Tour. Agust D will now perform a third date (June 9) in Bangkok’s Impact Arena. The rapper is also holding a third concert date (June 16) at the Singapore Indoor Stadium.
Suga’s world tour kicks off in April starting with numerous dates in the U.S. before returning to Asia in May. The final dates of the concert tour bring Min Yoongi back to Seoul in the latter part of June.
Suga had previously confirmed the world tour in February 2023. The BTS rapper celebrated the announcement with ARMY, expressing his excitement for performing for them during the tour. BIG HIT Entertainment announced Suga’s first solo album ‘D-Day’ on April 2, 2023.
‘D-Day’ is Suga’s first solo album that will get a physical release. He had previously released the mixtape ‘Agust D’ in August 2016 although the album was not available outside of Korea. He released the second mixtape ‘D-2’ in 2020.
ARMY will also get a first-hand look at how Suga worked on his latest album through a new documentary. ‘SUGA: Road to D-Day’ will follow Min Yoongi as he finds inspiration to work on the new album. The documentary will also feature the BTS rapper’s interactions with artists around the world. ‘SUGA: Road to D-Day’ will stream on Weverse and Disney+ this April.
Suga Agust D Tour kicks off in Belmont Park on April 26 followed by dates in Newark, Los Angeles, and Oakland. The album ‘D-Day’ is dropping on April 21, 2023, at 1:00 PM KST. ‘SUGA: Road to D-Day’ is available for pre-order on Weverse and will begin streaming on April 21, 2023.
SEVENTEEN is preparing to release their 10th mini album ‘FML’ this month and the group has just unveiled the tracklist. A brief teaser dubbed the “Hidden” version confirms the surprising title track. It also reveals three new songs performed by the SVT teams.
SEVENTEEN Drops ‘FML’ Hidden Ver. Tracklist
The official SEVENTEEN Twitter account shared the “Hidden” versiontracklist teaser for ‘FML’. It confirms that the boy group’s 10th mini album will consist of six new songs. The first title track is “F*ck My Life” while the second title track remains unknown.
SEVENTEEN (세븐틴) 10th Mini Album 'FML' Track List (Hidden Ver.)
The official track list also includes new songs from each SEVENTEEN team. The Hiphop Team, which consists of S. Coups, Wonwoo, Mingyu, and Vernon, have produced the track “Fire.” For their song, the Vocal Team comprised of Woozi, Jeonghan, Joshua, DK, and Seungkwan chose “먼지 (Dust)”.
Additionally, the Performance Team (Hoshi, Jun, THE8, and Dino) has a new song “I Don’t Understand But I Luv U.” The track is inspired by a fan comment during SEVENTEEN’s Weverse live broadcast where an international CARAT expressed their love for the group despite the language barrier. A fifth track “April Shower” was also confirmed in the video.
‘FML’ will be SEVENTEEN’s 10th mini album and their first group release for the year. The group’s special subunit BSS (DK, Hoshi, and Seungkwan) had previously released their comeback single album ‘Second Wind’ on February 6, 2023. This marked BooSeokSoon’s first comeback after five years of being inactive.
SEVENTEEN recently got together to celebrate Mingyu‘s birthday. The group’s official Twitter account shared a photo of all 13 members enjoying a meal together. Kim Mingyu is a member of the SVT Hiphop Team and he turned 26 on April 6, 2023.
Yes, you read that title right. Just when you thought that second-generation girl groups have resurfaced and reentered our consciousness and conversations in 2021, the ladies that dominated the airwaves from 2007 to 2011 have gotten even more active in 2022, much to their fans’ delight. Well, we deserve that, after feeling like we’re being trolled since the pandemic started of rumors, speculations, and teasing statements that this so-and-so group will reunite or, gasp, release new music!
So, here’s a look back on those activities only second gen queens are capable of doing and made us feel blessed this 2022.
Girls’ Generation
Can you believe it has been five years since Girls’ Generation released new music? The legends, queens of k-pop, and the nation’s girl group was last seen promoting (more of releasing as they just spent a week doing the usual rounds of music shows) as a group with the Holiday Night album and the Holiday and All Night single releases. Shortly after that, three members – Tiffany, Sooyoung, and Seohyun left SM Entertainment, making fans speculate about the uncertain future of the group, although the three (and SM Entertainment) were vehement in saying the group hasn’t disbanded despite their departure from the group’s mother agency.
The next few years after 2017 had the girls focus on their individual careers, with Taeyeon releasing more solo material, Hyoyeon reinventing herself as a DJ and dance artist, Tiffany releasing all-English albums internationally before returning to Korea as a stage actress, Sooyoung, Seohyun, Yuri, and Yoona dabbling into music once in a while as they went full throttle as actresses on TV and film, and Sunny establishing herself as a TV personality. The five girls who remained with SM Entertainment even formed a sub-unit in 2018 called Oh!GG that released the hit single Li’l Touch, which also got Sones around the world a bit worried as to the status of the whole group, now that the SM-loyal girls had their own group.
Fears were assuaged a bit in 2011 as all nine members were guests in Yoo Jaesuk’s You Quiz on the Block and hinted at the group’s future projects. While the girls were separated into two groups (ugh, the things we did during the pandemic), all nine assured the fans that the group hasn’t disbanded and there will be activities to commemorate the group’s 15th anniversary in 2022.
Alas, we weren’t taken for a ride because, in May 2022, SM officially announced a comeback for Girls’ Generation as a full group. An 8-episode variety show Soshi TamTam started airing on cable channel JTBC in July, and finally, in August, the group’s seventh full-length album, Forever 1, hit the stores. The queens (including the three who left SM already) even participated in SM Town Live 2022 also in August. To cap the album’s promotions, the girls held a special concert entitled Long Lasting Love in September.
Our Sone hearts are full, but here’s hoping we won’t have to wait another five years for the group to release new music. After all, even the non-SM girls were super active participants in Forever 1, with Sooyoung and Tiffany co-writing two of the songs in the album. So, there’s no question that all eight members are still fully committed to the group, and only their schedules will tell if we will be getting new music from them in the coming years.
Kara
Now here’s one group that can truly rival SNSD’s legacy but had to go through quite a rocky road up until their reunion which finally happened in November 2022. Following the great rivalry between SM’s SES and DSP’s Fin.KL of the first generation, the two companies’ group continued this tradition, with Kara also producing massive hits such as Honey, Lupin, Step, and Mister. The group also established a solid career in Japan, just as GG started in 2009 and 2010. 2014 also proved to be a challenging year for both groups as Jessica mysteriously departed SNSD while Nicole and Jiyoung decided not to renew their contracts with the company, reducing the group’s member count to four, although a new member, Youngji, was recruited to the group the next year via a reality show.
The group with the updated line-up released a couple of more hits such as Mamma Mia and Cupid before 2016, when the three original members of the lineup – Gyuri, Seungyeon, and Hara decided not to renew their contracts with DSP. This left Youngji as the remaining member still DSP, prompting the agency to state that the group has disbanded. When asked about this, the individual members dispelled this, claiming that should the right opportunities and schedules would allow, Kara can return as a full group.
Alas, tragedy struck when in November 2019, Hara left, which further cast doubts on Kara’s future. But then, early this year, all five members – Gyuri, Seungyeon, Nicole, Jiyoung, and Youngji had a photoshoot to commemorate the group’s 15th year. Reunion speculations were fanned once more, as observers noted that Hara was tagged in the reunion photos. Reports also claimed that the group is discussing the possibility of recording a reunion single.
Kamilias in particular and second gen kpop fans in general rejoiced when it was announced that not only will the butt-dance queens release a reunion single, but they will actually be releasing a 15th anniversary EP album. Released on November 29 by RBW, Move Again contains four songs – When I Move (the title track), Happy Hour (which the five members had a hand at writing), Shout It Out, and Oxygen. Not only that; the queens made a splash in the 2022 MAMA Awards where they had their comeback stage and a mini medley of Mister, STEP, and Lupin. Spell g-o-o-s-b-u-m-p-s as even the current generation of idol groups were seen thoroughly enjoying the five-minute nostalgia trip and were left wanting more!
Meanwhile, the music video for When I Movewas released on November 29. And yes, the 15-year-old girl group had their first music program win after such a long time in Music Bank on December 16.
Apink
Now here’s a bittersweet turn of events for the eternal fairies of k-pop. While SNSD and Kara (with Wonder Girls and 2NE1) did rule this generation, they did not follow through with the sweet and innocent concepts of their companies’ seniors, SES and Fin.KL, were known for. The stronger and fiercer concept that these groups pursued left fans of the first generation K-pop acts longing for the days when their idols were more feminine and wholesome. This left a niche for erstwhile ACube (a Cube Entertainment subsidiary) rookies Apink to dominate. And in 2014 when Nicole and Jiyoung left Kara, Jessica left SNSD, and Bom got into a drug scandal, Apink dropped NoNoNo, Mr. Chu, and LUV one after another. So, while the year was considered a dark one in K-pop (not to mention the Sewol Ferry disaster also happened the same year), Apink thrived.
Fast forward to 2021, when the scandal-free group was about to start the celebration of their 10th year after three successive hits amidst the hugely successful concept change to a more sophisticated image starting in I’m So Sick and continuing with %% and Dumhdurum, it was indefinitely postponed because of the group’s first major scandal — leader Chorong’s involvement in a bullying and underage drinking exposé by her former high school classmate. While Chorong apologized for the underage drinking issue, it took months for the parties to clear the air on the bullying scandal. Alas, when Chorong’s accuser finally cleared her name, 2021 was already coming to a close and not a lot of time was left to stage the group’s anniversary comeback. To top things off, Naeun left the groups’ company (which at this time already went by Play M Entertainment) and signed with YG as an actress. However, the group continued as six members.
Thus, Apink’s 10th-year celebrations and comeback did happen but only after months of postponement. And when the comeback was finalized for April, rumors of Naeun’s departure from the group intensified as she only participated in the making of the album and music video, but begged off from participating in the group’s promotion. Fans were a bit puzzled as to why Naeun didn’t participate in the promotions of Dilemma, the title track from the album Horn, the group’s anniversary album because she was already done filming her drama Ghost Doctor and wasn’t signed to a new one yet while the group’s main vocalist, Eunji was committed to filming two dramas (Work Later, Drink Now and Blind) and also preparing for a solo music comeback. Speculations were laid to rest when it was revealed that Naeun will be leaving the group in April, two months after Horn’s release and only days before the group’s 11th anniversary.
So, it does appear that Naeun’s departure was more economic than anything – she was just not keen on splitting her income with five other people anymore. It wasn’t like she was the most overworked among the members. However, she was the most popular in terms of CFs and social media following, and she may have realized she has the option of using this popularity to further her own career, without having to constantly share the spotlight with others. A bit selfish but thoroughly practical, and with Naeun sharing everything since her debut in 2011, she really doesn’t need to prove her intentions nor defend her actions.
And not only have these three groups shown some sort of activity for the past couple of years. T-ara released a comeback album in 2021 and After School and 9Muses performed in Jaejae’s MMTG web program in 2021. Meanwhile, this year had Sistar and 2NE1 holding reunion performances in You Hee-yeol’s Sketchbook’s final episode and Coachella, respectively. And get this: ex-groupmates HyunA and Sohyun have re-followed each other on IG and have since then exchanged sweet comments. Is a 4Minute reunion too much to ask? Here’s to more 2nd gen reunions and comebacks in 2023!
Featured Image: Screengrab from Kara’s “When I Move” video.
TRIGGER WARNING: This article is pretty much triggering to die-hard BLINKs. Reader discretion and levelheadedness are advised.
If you are to ask anyone which is the most famous and powerful girl group in the world, it’s almost certain that the answer is BLACKPINK. Their tremendous achievements since debuting in 2016 are unparalleled and at this point, can only be compared to that other group from HYBE, BTS. Yes, the level Blackpink is on at the moment is practically only occupied by only them and BTS, which happens to be the biggest pop group in the world. Even the most credible and established media outfits in the world like Bloomberg and Rolling Stone Magazine recognize BLACKPINK‘s impact on the international, not just Korean, music scene. And now that BTS as a group is on hiatus as individual members are pursuing solo projects and fulfilling their military duties to their country one by one, it may seem that BLACKPINK is given the strategic position to dominate the music industry by themselves.
But with all these enviable triumphs, many speculate that a doomsday scenario is unfolding with BLACKPINK. Domestically underperforming releases, lousy tour stages, those sporadic comebacks that as of late have started underwhelming even die-hard BLINKs, and that foreboding Rolling Stones interview are leading people to believe that the Born Pink era is starting to feel like the group singing the opening lines of Frank Sinatra’s My Way, which goes, “And now the end is here…” Let’s look at these tell-tale signs and evaluate whether we are reading too much into them or if it is really the beginning of the end for the group.
The disturbing Rolling Stones interview
A couple of months before the release of Born Pink, BLACKPINK added another feather to their already overflowing cap by being the second K-Pop group and the third girl group to grace the cover of Rolling Stones. All members did share their struggles that go all the way back since their trainee days, which is a tale as old as K-pop time so fans went “heard that before.” But then, Jisoo started getting subdued, which is definitely not the usually cheerful and energetic Jisoo in stages, not Jisoo in that Netflix docu, not Jisoo in public appearances, not Jisoo in Blackpink House (can we all admit that Jisoo was the only source of high energy in some rather boring episodes), not Jisoo generally. AT ALL. In a suddenly honest take, Jisoo expressed her exhaustion when she was asked about her condition that day and even opened up about her leg injury and how she is a bit relieved that they will be more focused on recording the songs rather than learning the choreography for their upcoming comeback releases, so she will have more time to rest rather than aggravating her poor feet’s condition. That is so not Jisoo!
As the interview progressed, Jisoo dropped more anxiety-inducing hints at the group’s eventual dissolution. When asked about her perspective on life after becoming an internationally celebrated superstar, she gave an answer that can send even the most hardcore BLINKs nonplussed, saying that the way people looked up to her as a member of BLACKPINK “doesn’t resonate” with her much. Ms. Jisoo’s unimpressed view of international stardom was furthered when she added that she had always been a free soul and because of her massive popularity, she is bummed that she couldn’t move around as much as she wished. Then, the proverbial final nail to the coffin was hammered when she admitted to having always considered establishing her savings so that she can move to another country, although she still isn’t final about her future plans and continues to search for her life’s trajectory.
As if the hearts of the BLINKs while reading this interview haven’t been crushed enough, Jisoo went further by sharing that she didn’t enjoy the attention she gets as an idol. But wait! Jennie and Lisa also added their two cents to the status of the group discussion, with the Solo-ist saying, “Even if we’re 70 and have different lives, I feel like we are still BLACKPINK,” and Lalisa adding that BLACKPINK can always reunite after several more years to perform like Spice Girls did, even with husbands and kids and all.
GIRLS! At this point, we should be talking about your next comeback in 2023, not a reunion in 2032! Why are those answers making me want to cry? Why???
Long breaks between comebacks, YG support of individual activities
Yes, we know that YG Entertainment is infamous/notorious/evil for putting their talents on long hiatuses in the guise of “making sure they only release quality music” and “making sure they are well-rested and healthy”. Whether those “excuses” are valid or not is beside the point, as YG-stans recognize that these long breaks are really just manifestations of typical YG behavior of putting their groups in the legendary “YG dungeon”. But then, not even BIGBANG had a hiatus that took close to a year and nine months. 2NE1 did after 2014 and we all know how that ended. So, is the series of events that happened to Cl, Bom, Dara, and Minzy bound to happen to Jennie, Lisa, Rose, and Jisoo?
Not really, argued some fans, as the event that triggered the chain of events that turned the 2NE1 hiatus to eventual disbandment was Bom’s “scandal”. Nothing of this sort has happened (so far) with BLACKPINK. In fact, vis-a-vis other active groups, BLACKPINK is currently the only active girl group that went on a hiatus for so long without a scandal. Red Velvet started off their long break because of Wendy’s accident but then continued on as Irene’s “attitude problem” was revealed. Apink had to postpone their 10th-year anniversary comeback because of bullying allegations against leader Chorong.
Jennie may have been embroiled in a romance “scandal” with BTS’ V, but that type of “scandal” doesn’t merit delayed comebacks. So that does mean that YGE, with the girl’s agreement, voluntarily put a stop to group promotions and instead focus on other individual career gigs. Jennie, Rosé, and Lisa have already started their careers as soloists, with the latter two releasing solo music during the pandemic/prolonged BP hiatus. All four have been flying worldwide to the most high-profile fashion events. Rose has also appeared in variety programs while Lisa has gone all the way to China to flex her mentorship skills in idol survival shows there. Alas, Jisoo has debuted as an actress in no less than the controversial k-drama Snowdrop.
Thus, BLINKS are faced with a chicken and egg conundrum: Are BP group activities getting sparse because YG has realized that the girls individually can still rake in $$$ for the company minus the pressure on the girls (that they need to churn perfect songs and impeccable stages all the time) and the cashout from the company (YG doesn’t spend anything on Rose’s YSL, Jennie’s Calvin Klein, Jisoo’s Dior, or Lisa’s Celine campaigns; on the contrary, they earn from the companies that pay them for the girls’ time). Makes perfect business sense, eh? Good for the company that earns a lot, the girls in the sense that they still get international exposure for less effort, and casual fans who still get to see the girls on ads, billboards, and magazine covers even if they don’t release new music as BP. But then, that’s also bad for the girls who may still hunger for their artistic sides to be harnessed more and BLINKs who love their music as a group and long for more interactions among the four.
Alas, there are other reasons also related to YG, such as:
a. The group’s western orientation.
With YG’s push for the girls to collaborate with Lady Gaga, Cardi B, Dua Lipa, and Selena Gomez, the group may have become too western for Korean taste. While BLACKPINK‘s western expansion has seen more success compared to similar efforts of second-generation groups like Girls’ Generation and Wonder Girls, the sense of detachment of the K-BLINKs (especially paired with that overly long hiatus) is reminiscent of the instability of WG when they returned from their prolonged US engagement. And when the group’s power in the domestic market is shaky, no amount of international success can compensate for that (refer to Wonder Girls, NU’EST pre-PD101, CROSSGENE).
b. The over-dependence on Teddy for their music.
Teddy is YG through and through, and that includes his speed in producing new music. Teddy is definitely no Brave Bros. or Woozi/Bumzu who can finish songs after confining themselves in a room for a couple of hours. And through the years, YG (as in Mr. Yang Hyunsuk, former Boy of Seo Taiji and Boys before becoming one of the most important people in the Korean music industry) in his relentless pursuit of premium quality music, has been okay with this speed and has been reliant to him and him alone for most of the music of the company’s groups.
[Exclusive] @BLACKPINK will change their agency to YG affiliate @THEBLACKLABEL, founded by Teddy, according to our sources. The industry insider added that the discussions over changing the girls' management have been made since early this year. #BLACKPINK#블랙핑크pic.twitter.com/dVup3zPfTC
c. YG’s decision to take care of the girl’s well-being.
Especially after the girls’ 2020 tour, which took a huge toll on the girls’ well-being (and verified by Jennie in the Rolling Stones interview), the company did decide to really give the foursome sufficient time to recuperate. This, for some, may be considered as just some lousy excuse at the expense of comeback-hungry BLINKs.
d. BLACKPINK contracts will be expiring soon.
As in soon, in 2023 to be exact. And with everybody including their mom leaving YG, from iKON to even actor Gang Dongwon, rumors are rife that BLACKPINK will not renew their contracts and will instead move to YG’s associate label The Black Label. Makes sense? And in the biggest plot twist of the year, what if Black Label talent Somi joins BLACKPINK? Mindblown!
3. Fans are pushing for girl groups outside the Big 4
While the span of almost two years doesn’t sound too long, in the cutthroat competitive world of K-Pop industry, that period was already enough for agencies to debut tons of groups that have eventually composed the 4th generation of K-pop artists. So, while BLACKPINK and Red Velvet took a backseat, new groups debuted and not only became rookies but monster rookies that dominated the Korean music charts, particularly in digital sales, as expected of girl groups. The thing about this is that contrary to expectations that these groups would come from SM, YG, JYP, and HYBE, only four of them — aespa, NMixx, Le Sserafim, and NewJeans, are backed up by the Big 4 entertainment agencies. The rest who have also experienced massive success in this rather limited time period such as IVE, StayC, and Billie, not to mention the late 3rd gen (G)-IDLE, Everglow, and fromis_9, plus the late bloomers Oh My Girl, are not from the Big 4 at all.
But aside from the increasing competition, the emergence of these 4th gen acts may also make YGE realize that they are already late in the game, which may propel them to fast-track the debut of their 4th gen girl group. Alas, this indeed happened as of December 30, as the company released a teaser of their new group amidst the PR nightmare of the YG talent exodus that started the day before and continued the following day. The splash of the “Baby Monster” sneak peek was overshadowed by the mass exodus of YG talents, including the rumor that BLACKPINK will transfer to The Black Label, as what happened to BIGBANG‘s Taeyang.
Not only that, but as Korean entertainment companies in the past have shown, BLACKPINK may start to be neglected as the company’s focus and resources might be redirected to Baby Monster. We’ve all seen this happen before — f(x) had to give way to Red Velvet, Red Velvet had to share the spotlight with aespa; Miss A had to give way to Twice, and Twice (despite being the Nation’s girl group) had to share favored child status with ITZY. We also saw how everyone consoled themselves with the BLACKPINK debut as the hopes of a 2NE1 comeback in 2016 got dimmer.
4. The lackluster and lackadaisical Born Pink tour
It’s quite an accepted reality that Jennie is not the most enthusiastic stage performer. But when Lisa and Rose interact coldly with each other and the rest of the girls make mistakes in their choreographies, alarm bells should sound, right? The three are known to be very precise and not execute shortcuts in choreography, but multiple clips of the performances where the members seemingly forget their steps or just simply not putting that much energy into what is otherwise very dynamic choreography went viral. It has triggered fans who have to spend so much to attend the shows and wait for close to two years for this comeback. As fans grew hungry for anything BLACKPINK since 2020, the least they expected were energetic stages, also considering that the girls had so much time to prepare. It does feel like, with all factors considered, the girls may just not be that interested in presenting flawless performances, or in performing at all.
#BLACKPINK has successfully ended their last concert of European tour at #Amsterdam, Netherlands on December 22 (U.S. time), announced YG Entertainment on Tuesday.
This has led people to think that maybe the girls are just winging everything until their YG contracts expire, as it feels like their hearts aren’t really into the comeback. This ties back to some of what Jisoo said in the Rolling Stones interview, that she feels that performing on stage is more of something that she does to the fans rather than something she loves to do.
The Asian leg of the Born Pink Tour is still to happen in 2023, and the European and US legs have seen the girls improve… a little. We’ll have to wait and see if Lisa’s return to Bangkok and Rose and Jennie’s homecoming of sorts in Australia and New Zealand can revive the missing spark in the girls.
Ultimately, unless official word from YG Entertainment and the girls is released, we can still consider BLACKPINK an ongoing concern. We fervently hope that even with the mess YG Entertainment is in right now (or has been in since Yang Hyunsuk and Seungri’s involvement in the Burning Sun issue), that our BLAKCPINK girls will rise above all of these unscathed and cotinue to dominate in all our areas for years to come.
The case of DIA is very curious because they seem to have what it takes to become the breakout group of 2016, especially since they had a member from I.O.I: Chaeyeon. She was one of the visual centers of I.O.I who was anticipated to become the next Bae Suzy. These factors certainly beg the question, why had DIA languished seven years into their careers? Why can’t the group seem to catch a break?
The History of DIA
It was February 2015 and the entire industry of Korean pop music was reeling from a rather eventful 2014. Ladies’ Code met an accident where two of its members passed away; 25 people died after a ventilation grate collapses during a 4minute concert; members quit their groups – Kris and Luhan from EXO, Jessica from SNSD, Thunder and Lee Joon from MBLAQ, and Jiyoung and Nicole from Kara, among others; B.A.P files lawsuit against their agency for maltreatment; the father of Super Junior‘s Leeteuk murders his parents before ending his own life; and alas, Park Bom gets embroiled in a drug scandal. All of these happened amidst the national tragedy of the MV Sewol sinking. By this time, it seemed that the entire country deserved a break from all these unfortunate events.
So, it was rather auspicious for MBK to announce plans of debuting a new girl group. MBK, the company of T-ara, a group that was still very much detested by the public in 2015 after the “bullying scandal” between Hwayoung and the other members, said that they are planning to stage a reality show entitled T-ara’s Little Sister Girl Group and form a new group. Months after, the company decided to cancel the plan and decided to choose from among their current trainees who the members of the new group will be. MBK announced a line-up with six members: Eunice, Huihyeon (aka Cathy), Jenny, Yebin, Eunjin, and Chaeyeon, with Seunghee added to the line-up before the group’s debut in September. The group released their self-titled debut studio album, Do It Amazing with the single Somehow, whose music video was filmed in Hong Kong.
The album peaked at number 11 on the Gaon Album Chart and the song charted at #152. The performance was promising for a debut group, which means it wasn’t really considered a flop, but definitely far from the group making a splash. Also, considering that DIA was marketed as the new T-ara, Make It Amazing and Somehow definitely paled in comparison to their sunbaenim’s debut Absolute First Album, which peaked at number 2, and their debut single Lie, which charted in Billboard’s K-pop Hot 100, all amidst of early line-up changes in the highly competitive year of 2009. But then, many commented on the group members’ freshness and Chaeyeon’s beauty, so people were reasonably optimistic about the group’s future.
But then, as what their senior group experienced, DIA also became subject to line-up changes as soon as their debut activities ended. Eunchae (introduced as Chaewon) joined as a new member in March 2016, virtually replacing Seunghee, who was confirmed to have left the group a month later. Before that, Cathay and Chaeyeong took a hiatus from group activities to participate in Produce 101, which was quite successful for the girls as both gained a following from the show (although Cathy was a victim of the Mnet evil edit) and Chaeyeon finished 7th. DIA‘s first mini-album Happy Ending was released on June 14, along with the music video for the lead single On the Road on the same day. Chaeyeon did return to her group for this comeback while a sub-init of I.O.I promoted Whatta Man, making the DIA line-up complete for this release. Both EP and single outperformed their debut efforts, with Happy Ending selling close to 10,000 copies by the end of 2016 (compared to only close to 2,5000 Do It Amazing sold) and On the Road downloaded more than 81,000 times at peaking at the charts at #48, which remains the group’s highest-charting song up to date.
In September 2016, the group released a Harry Potter-themed album titled Spell, with Mr. Potter as the lead single. Although the album fared better than its predecessor, the song brought the group back to outside the top 100 in the charts, as Mr. Potter only managed close to 23,000 downloads and peaked at #103.
2017 saw new members, Jueun and Somyi, who participated in the group’s second studio album YOLO, which was released in April. The album contained fourteen tracks, with the lead single titled Will You Go Out with Me?
YOLO peaked at number 3 in the album charts with more than 18,000 units sold, while Will You Go Out With Mebrought back the group to the top 100, as it peaked at #78 with close to 28,000 digital downloads. Four months later, the group released their third mini-album titled Love Generation, with a repackaged version released two months later. Although the album performed better than most of their releases, the singles Can’t Stop and Good Night was nowhere in Gaon’s digital sales charts.
In May the following year, Eunjin announced her departure from the group, citing health problems. With six members remaining, MBK announced a DIA comeback in July, which was already postponed as the comeback was previously announced to happen in April. DIA ultimately released their fourth EP Summer Ade on August 9, 2018, with the title track Woo Woo. Although the release didn’t do much in terms of the group’s standing, they did receive their first music show win on SBS MTV’s The Show, so at the end of the day, the group still benefited from it.
The group did not return until March 2019 with their fifth EP titled Newtro alongside its title track Woowa. Four months later, Jenny left the group due to health problems with her knee.
5 years ago today, DIA released their 2nd Mini Album ‘Spell’ with the title track 'Mr Potter' pic.twitter.com/a1fGML21tw
On May 25, 2020, it was revealed that DIA would make a comeback with their sixth EP Flower 4 Seasons on June 10, marked their first release under PocketDol Studio, which is just MBK rebranded. It was also confirmed that the group will promote with five members as a unit without Chaeyeon and Somyi. Thre was also a bit of intrigue for this comeback as apparently, one of DIA’s former members, Seunghee (as the last member to be included in the original 2015 line-up and also the first one to leave the group in 2016) has returned to PocketDol. However, she has become a producer of the company and only deals with the agency’s boy groups, so she shut down any speculation that she would work with her former group in any capacity.
Since June 2020, the group has not staged any activities. Moreover, PocketDol confirmed that Somyi, the member who didn’t participate in the group’s last comeback, had already terminated her contract with the company and left DIA. On the other hand, Chaeyeon is still under the company, although she has been very active in her acting career, particularly after experiencing a rise in her popularity after appearing as the female lead in the KBS drama The King’s Affection with SF9‘s Rowoon and Park Eunbin (Hot Stove League, Do You Like Brahms?). She is set to star opposite BtoB‘s Sungjae in the MBC drama Golden Spoon.
What went wrong?
With the company finally announcing that the group will release a final album before officially disbanding, we are now left with the question, what went wrong with DIA? Here are some theories that fans themselves have presented as to why the group ultimately flopped.
No opportunity to display their charms
This can all be attributed to MBK’s general incompetence. They were just zero creativity in terms of the concepts DIA showcased during the years they were active. All their music videos showed a lack of storyline, so it felt like the group’s videos only had the camera operator tail the girls on their day off or in whatever activity they could think of. The only music video the group had that was obviously heavy on concept was the one for Mr. Potter. But even that one had people scratching their heads as there was this person with a rabbit’s head, then the girls doing a dance using their suspenders, then some scenes on a train (still with the human rabbit) that finally make people remember the Hogwarts Express, before finally having some of the members ride broomsticks, which can be a reference to Quidditch. The video ends up being disjointed, as people end up not being sure of what the song is all about.
The lineup changes are not justified.
We get it, the group, just like most groups with IOI members, end up being (insert IOI member name) and friends. This is why it was a huge injustice to the group when they added new members to compensate for the departure of a member, only for these new members to not be given the platform to really showcase their talents through a subunit and instead just continue on as Chaeyeon’s back-up girls. Alas, nobody really knew them.
DIA remained a nugu group
Chaeyeon is one of the more popular idols in K-pop and that became a problem for DIA. That is because the majority of Korean public only knows about Chaeyeon as an individual rather than DIA as a whole. Alas, her popularity did not contribute to the group’s popularity, as it seems Chaeyeon’s identity was not tightly knitted with the group’s, unlike for example, how Eunji’s and Naeun’s acting careers further raised Apink’s profile or how Jisoo is recognized as Blackpink’s Jisoo even in (or despite) her debut acting appearance in Snowdrop. So, the question of whether you should already be famous before joining a group or get more recognition as a member of a group first before getting additional popularity for your group is more like a chicken or egg conundrum. Unfortunately, in DIA’s case, Chayeon’s fame did not rub off on her group.
Alas, with the announcement of DIA’s disbandment, we can only wish all the girls good luck in their future endeavors.
Featured Image: Screenshot from DIA’s “Mr Potter” Official Music video.
K-pop idol groups fading from the limelight through disbandment shortly after their debut is a sad but common reality. However, there are a few groups that had things to their advantage at the start but still struggled in terms of popularity and eventually lost their battle against irrelevance. Here are four groups that, unfortunately, we may not see much of anymore.
HOTSHOT
This one is gonna hurt a lot of K-pop observers because HOTSHOT was definitely one of the most talented groups in K-pop. If you need more evidence to prove this, look no further than Produce 101 Season 2, where you can watch Ha Sungwon finishing in the top 11 of the program, and therefore securing a spot in the project group WANNA ONE, while Noh Taehyun being in charge of the choreography of his group’s staging of Ed Sheeran’s Shape of You. Oh, and don’t forget that first evaluation performance of the two to Block B’s Very Good. Based on that, you can’t really help but wonder why HOTSHOT, with overly talented members and all, became lukewarm and eventually faded into disbandment.
But Produce 101 Season 2 was not the only program where HOTSHOT’s members were able to display their talents. While Sungwon and Taehyun participated in Produce 101, another two joined another idol survival show, The Unit. Timoteo, who happened to be an SM trainee and was slotted to join EXO, ended up 10th in the show. It was a spot short of the final nine members who made up the show’s project group UNB. On the other hand, Hojung ranked 3rd and therefore promoted with UNB from April 2018 to January 2019. The thing about UNB was that initial plans were for the group to promote for seven months initially and if they proved successful, the project group’s activities would be extended for 25 months. The two EPs sold more than 46,000 copies each, which made people scratch their heads as to why they ceased their activities after only more than nine months.
As for HOTSHOT, they weren’t really popular to begin with, despite having outrageously talented members. They eventually got the boost they need with Taehyun and Sungwon’s exposure in PD101 S2 that their last release in 2018 fared better than their previous releases. However, it should be noted that this EP, Early Flowering, did not include Sungwon, as he was still with WANNA ONE until December of 2018. The EP was released a month before. Which begs the question, “why?’ Didn’t the company want to milk Sungwon’s newfound fame to the group’s benefit?
The group’s last song I Hate You (which was included in Early Flowering) would have greatly benefited from the push that Sungwon could have provided, had he been included. But then, Star Crew might have already envisioned a solo career for him post-WANNA ONE and may have already given up on HOTSHOT. What is more curious is that they included Hojung despite him still promoting with UNB. Moreover, Star Crew gave Taehyun his first solo project, an EP in January 2019 after promoting with JBJ from October 2017 to April 2018.
Finally, in March 2021, Star Crew formally announced the group’s disbandment, after more than two years of the group’s inactivity. Just like that.
Essential song: Real talk: Not one song in the group’s six-year-old discography really gave justice to Sungwon’s vocals, Taehyun’s dance moves, and Yoonsan’s rap skills, all of which are top-notch. Take a look at Step by Stepand I’m a Hotshot for their better songs.
Where are they now: Military enlistment was last heard of three members: Junhyuk enlisted in the military in January 2020, Hojung in May 2020, and Yoonsan also enlisted in 2021. Timoteo contributed a song to the Mr. Boss OST in 2021 and has been a guest in a couple of TV shows. Meanwhile, Taehyun and Sungwoon have launched solo careers. Sungwoon has also signed with BPM Entertainment (agency to Soyou, Huh Gak, three former members of GFriend, and Sungwoon’s PD101 castmate Samuel) and is set to release his latest EP with his new agency in February.
SNUPER
This is one group that did not really count on a lot of factors save for the songs that were meant to bring the group to the top. The six-member group was the first talents created by Windmay Entertainment, a company established by former JYP employees who had previously worked with Miss A and 2PM. The name of the group is actually short for “Higher than Super” which according to the group means that the goal is to come together as a group to enhance their strengths as individual supermen. The group also alluded to the similarity of their name to the cartoon character Snoopy who has a cute side, with their intense nature reflected in the word Super. So, Snoopy + Super = Snuper!
The six members of Snuper are quite interesting as well, which may have assured the group of at least a bit of public interest. Taewoong, the leader and rapper, was born in Japan to a Japanese dad and Korean mom and was a child actor before training as a singer-idol for a full seven years. Suhyun, the group’s main vocalist, named himself after his favorite actor Kim Soohyun and trained under Jellyfish Entertainment before shifting to Windmay. Sangil, the group’s other main vocalist, was working in a cafe when he was scouted for Snuper. Since his debut in Snuper, he has joined various singing and reality competitions such as The Unit, King of the Masked Singer, and Mr. Trot.
There’s also Woosung, who is the tallest in the group and has earned a reputation for his athletic prowess by winning the 60-meter dash in the ISACs three times. Sangho, the main dancer, was Sangil’s co-worker in the cafe and was also discovered there. Finally, there’s Sebin, the main rapper who is also the maknae and like Taewoong, was also a child actor before training to become an idol. He joined The Unit with Sangil.
Snuper’s last Japanese comeback was on August 8th, 2019 with Come Over, while their Korean comeback was even earlier, on October 8th, 2018 with You In My Eyes, which is is actually a re-release of a B-side from their Blossom EP. Perhaps their most popular songs are Platonic Love, Back:Hug, and You=Heaven, which are all produced by Sweetune, and thus have that retro-disco sound that should have assured the group of a cult following.
And that they did, but unfortunately, the group didn’t really garner traction in the Korean market. Their fandom, Swing, did not expand much in Korea, while the group became more popular in Korea. The group didn’t really face controversy, save for this one outfit guffaw when Starlights, VIXX’s fandom, pointed out that the outfits for their “It’s Raining” promotions resembled VIXX stage outfits too much. Other than that, Snuper pretty much had consistent comebacks and has actually toured overseas, performing in countries like Canada, the UAE, Russia, and Mexico.
So with members who sort of guaranteed international success (those Japanese members are moneymakers, for sure) and songs produced by Sweetune, architects of a number of career-defining songs for Infinite and Secret, why has Snuper not experienced breakthrough success even after six years? It may all be attributed to the inexperience of the company when it comes to promoting an idol group. With so much competition going on with the third generation of idol groups, there must be something for a group to specialize in so that they can be set apart from others. Otherwise, they will just blend in with other groups, which may have exactly happened to Snuper.
Essential songs: According to fans, the group’s three best songs include Platonic Love, Back: Hug, and The Star of Stars.
Where are they now: There has been no official disbandment announcement from the group’s agency and most members are supposed to be focusing on their military service. Member Sebin has been promoting with the group Omega X since its debut in June 2021.
CROSS GENE
Cross Gene is another group that somehow found success in Japan but not in Korea. This boy group started off very promising in 2012 with six members. The multiple ethnicities of the six members also may have made followers of k-pop music very curious, making their first release peak at a very respectable number 8 on the Gaon album charts. So, what exactly went wrong? It can be argued that the things that the group had to their advantage were also precisely what caused their popularity to not quite take off, at least in Korea. Thus, sad to say that to the newer fans of K-pop, the mention of this group’s name will elicit a few “nugu?” reactions.
As mentioned earlier, Cross Gene was a highly anticipated group to debut. The group’s agency, Amuse Korea, is originally a Japanese company that had Cross Gene as its first project in the Korean market. The company announced in 2012 that it will debut a group with members from Korea, China, and Japan. Among the members is Shin Wonho, who has already made TV appearances and ads, and Terada Takuya, who has been with the company as an actor and model. Thus, when the group debuted, there were three South Koreans (Shin, Sangmin, and Yongseok), two Chinese (Casper and J. G.), and one Japanese (Takuya). The difference in nationalities of the members also became the reason for the group’s name, as they are supposed to be a cross of various genes that will form one perfect group.
Six months after debuting, J.G. departed from the group to start a career as a solo artist, and Amuse immediately replaced him with Seyoung. Takuya was also relieved of his position as a leader and was replaced by Shin. After the member and position changes, the group debuted and promoted in Japan throughout 2013 with a debut single in February, a digital single in March, a concert in May, another digital single in August, a special photobook CD weeks later, two more concerts also in August, a Japanese website in September, three more Japanese digital singles, and three more live shows before 2013 ended. This meant that after debuting in Korea in June 2012, the group has not had any activity in the country since then.
The first half of 2014 was not packed with activity for the group’s Korean fandom either, as the group spent the first months of the year in the US to film a movie. Finally, Korean-based Cross Gene followers saw some activity when a visual teaser for their Korean comeback was released on April 6. Finally, a few days short of a two-year absence in the Korean music scene, the digital single Amazing (Bad Lady) was released on June 9. Casper had to beg off from promotions though, as he had an injury during preparations.
The song was passable, albeit going a bit under the radar as it doesn’t sound as flashy as their other previous songs. However, the group got a lot of buzz because of the song’s choreography, which involves a number of movements that were deemed by some TV stations as too racy for public exhibition. One such move involves the members motioning their golden-gloved hands in front of their crotch area in a circular motion. Another move involved the members raising their hips from a lying position. Now, if that’s not a sure-fire way to get the Korean TV censors’ tongues a-wagging, nothing will!
Another thing Cross Gene did that was the opposite of the common practice was that they translated their Japanese singles into Korean. In 2014, groups like Girl’s Day, Apink, and INFINITE, among others, debuted in the Japanese market by releasing Japanese versions of their Korean hits, and after charting with these songs, they finally came up with original Japanese songs. The opposite happened to Cross Gene, who released a Korean version of their Japanese hit Shooting Staras a follow-up to the controversial Amazing.
But while this era produced three singles – Amazing, Shooting Star, and Billion Dollar for Korea, the boys did not forget about their Japanese fanbase as they continued to conduct live Japanese performances and participate in music festivals in Japan. This continued in 2015, with the group starting the year with a Japanese single, Future. The single charted high in the country’s Oricon Charts, cementing the group’s popularity in Japan. The group did stage a comeback for Korea, the highly addictive and catchy Play With Me, which peaked at number 7 in the Gaon Album Charts. Then the group returned to Japan to release a new single.
Despite the obvious preference the group (or the company?) showed for conducting Japanese activities, the group still enjoyed relative success in Korea, where after three and half years since debuting, they successfully sold out their first Korean concert on December 23, 2015.
In 2016, it was revealed that Casper has left the group. Two years later, Takuya also left the group to focus on his modeling and acting careers. Before the pandemic hit in early 2020, it was revealed that Yongseok and Sangmin have not renewed their contracts with Amuse. But nothing has been formally announced in relation to Cross Gene’s disbandment, as the three have since then enlisted in the military.
Hi this is your annual reminder that Cross Gene is the most underrated group in the history of kpop pic.twitter.com/271Nqmjo1b
So, suffice to say that Cross Gene did not really live up to their potential in Korea because of their company’s decision to be more active in the Japanese market at the start of their careers. By the time they chose to increase their promotional activities more in Korea at the same level as their Japanese promotions in 2017 to 2019, they had to share the spotlight with new groups.
Essential songs: The group’s debut single, La-Di Da-Diwas catchy and is among a few K-pop debut singles that actually charted in Gaon. You cannot hear Amazingwithout remembering the iconic controversial circular crotch choreography. Finally, that “ppa ppa ppira ppa ppa ppira ppa” hook of Play With Me’s chorus is the stuff of legends.
Where are they now: With Seyoung’s formal announcement in December 2020 that he has left the group and not just the company, Cross Gene is down to three members – Shin, Sangmin, and Yongseok. And with the latter two not signed to Amuse anymore, expecting them to successfully conduct reunion projects with Shin once they all finish military service may be unrealistic.
DAL SHABET
The story of Dal Shabet is a rather sad tale of finding direction a tad too late and not striking while the iron is hot. Moreover, it is a bit unjust that the group had to endure bullying and harassment from a fandom of another group. All in all, this underrated group had tons of missed opportunities and was a victim of a series of unfortunate events that they don’t really deserve.
Dal Shabet debuted in 2011. It was a year that also debuted Brave Girls, Rania, and Apink and had groups like SISTAR and Girl’s Day started cementing their popularity. While Apink had cornered the public that longs for the cutesy and innocent concepts the 1st girl groups popularized, Dal Shabet had a shaky situation from the start. The thing about the group’s debut single, Supa Dupa Diva is that it was a “love it or hate it” kind of song. While its supporters propelled it to rank decently on music shows like Music Bank, where it went on to peak at 5th place, its haters declared it as not just the worst debut song, but the “worst song ever.”
But then, music industry people later voted for it as 2011’s second most addicting song with the second most popular choreography. Even unforgiving k-netz announced their change of hearts.
In August 2011, the group announced that their first comeback would be “funky” and the hate they received for releasing an incomprehensible debut single was added as their concept photos for the comeback. They were deemed “too sexual” for live television, which prompted the company to overhaul the concept to a more quirky and cutesy one with just a touch of naughtiness. Dal Shabet scored its first top 10 single in the Gaon Charts with Bling Bling.
The group had a run-on with fans of another group before the year ended, which left a somewhat bad taste to everything. It all started at the end of December 2011 at the SBS Gayo Daejun, when Dal Shabet and B1A4 had a collab stage. There was a lot of touching between the groups, which caused Bana, B1A4’s fandom to spread rumors about Darlings (Dal Shabet’s fandom) harassing Banas. The rumors heightened during the Idol Star Athletics Championships when rumors circulated that Darlings assaulted, kidnapped, and raped Banas. Police interfered and revealed that no such incidents took place. Happyface Entertainment released a statement about the rumors, imploring people to stop. And B1A4 fans took things a step further by hacking Dal Shabet’s website. Visitors to the website were met with pop-ups asking why Banas were being harassed by Darlings.
Serri responded to the rumors by posting requests on Twitter for people to stop spreading lies and rumors. More harassment incidences happened before Serri and the company threatened legal action. Then things died a natural death (or maybe people got scared?).
2012 had the group return with the powerful Hit U, which became Dal Shabet’s first album to reach number one in the Gaon Charts. But two months after ending activities for the comeback, the group’s leader Viki left the group to pursue a solo career. She was quickly replaced with a new member, Woohee. Serri then assumed leadership of the group as they staged their comeback in July with the single Mr. BangBang. By November, Dal Shabet staged another comeback with the EP Have, Don’t Have, and up to this point, the group had relatively been quite successful.
It was in their summer 2013 comeback that Dal Shabet had their first brush of controversy as TV stations announced that the lyrics to their single Be Ambitious were unfit for public broadcast due to sexual content, and therefore they would not allow the song to be played in their shows or allow the group to promote it in their music programs. Happy Face Entertainment did comply by changing the lyrics in questions. However, weeks after, a men’s rights group ‘Man of Korea’ filed an injunction to completely ban the further distribution of the song claiming it deprecates Korean men who are subject to the country’s mandatory enlistment. Days later, Man of Korea and Happy Face came to an agreement with the former dropping their injunction request.
In 2014, the group went full-fledged sexy with their comeback B.B.B, which they first performed in the celebrity military reality show Real Men. By this time, the girls were quite popular throughout the country, but a couple of medical incidents affected some members. Subin got into a car accident in May 2014, where she had to undergo surgery for injuries. In September, Woohee was also hospitalized for a collapsed lung.
2015 saw the group embroiled in another controversy as the title track of their comeback Joker was banned by KBS because of its explicit choreography, with the song’s lyrics pointed out as being suggestive. You see, the English word “joker” sounds similar to the Korean expletive “jot kuh” which refers to the enormity of the male anatomy. Considering the group’s previous single B. B. B., which stands for “Big Baby Baby”, people were quick to point out the sexual innuendo “Joker” implied.
The end of 2015 revealed that Jiyul and Kaeun would be leaving the group, which would reduce the member count of the group to four. The group staged their comeback on January 5 with the retro-sounding Someone Like U, which actually charted in Japan and China. Nine months later, they released FRI. SAT. SUN. This would be the last comeback of the group.
In 2017, Happy Face Entertainment announced that Subin will be joining the reality television series The Unit, but because of schedule conflicts, she was replaced by Serri and Woohee.
However, before the year ended, the company announced that members Serri, Subin, and Ahyoung decided to leave the company after their contracts expired. Ahyoung transferred to SidusHQ, Serri was eliminated from The Unit and placed 23rd, while Woohee placed seventh and secured herself a place in the show’s female team.
Since then, the group has held a photo exhibition and a mini-concert in October 2019, with six members, including Jiyul and Kaeun. But then the company has already become more focused on promoting its new girl group, Dreamcatcher. Due to this, a lot of supposed Happy Face support for Dal Shabet has been diverted.
Essential songs:Dal Shabet definitely has a great discography Mr. BangBang, B. B. B., Pink Rocket, Have Don’t Have, Joker, and Someone Like U are all catchy AF.
Where are they now? All members are pursuing acting careers, with Subin and Serrri the only ones also doing a lot of music work.
With a good number of programs featuring the “golden age of K-pop” such as Jaejae’s MMTG, Ms. Back, and Mamadol, it is a fervent wish for these groups to experience a return to popularity because they truly deserve it.
By 2020, Apink has established itself as one of the most enduring acts of K-pop. A year short of celebrating a decade in the Korean music industry, Apink has amassed feats not a lot of pop groups, especially girl groups, have achieved. They have survived the 7-year curse and still continue to release music with resounding success while their contemporaries even struggle to keep their lineup intact. They took the chance of changing their image quite late in their careers at the risk of alienating their core fanbase who may never accept the idea that their innocent girls are now singing more sophisticated music. The risk paid off and they have been reintroduced to a younger generation of fans while still keeping most of their original fanbase.
Throughout the nine years that the group has been together, they have had only one member quit their lineup and the circumstances apparently didn’t involve animosity, with Yookyung even appearing in a couple of Instagram posts of the members since her departure from the group. The scandals that involved Apink were the type that actually gave the group added sympathy from the public instead of negatively affecting their reputations, such as ARMY using the availability of their concert tickets as their “dry run” to see how fast they can sell out theirs. There was also that saesang who has threatened Naeun for years, which caused the group to cancel some appearances. Finally, there was the KBS Song Festival of 2019 when their performance was abruptly cut to give more time to younger groups. Free from scandal throughout their careers, with every comeback successful for the past nine years, a couple of members also venturing into successful acting careers (Eunji and Naeun), and three members also releasing solo material (Eunji, Hayoung, and Namjoo), Apink was on their way to achieving what very few girl groups have before them – celebrating their 10th year in the business while still quite active in releasing music.
Then, things went bad.
For the past couple of years, the Korean entertainment industry has been flooded with bullying allegations. While entertainers from Hollywood got canceled mostly from claims of people getting sexually harassed by some of the industry’s biggest names, everyone in Korean entertainment, from up and coming actors to comedians and idols keep getting accused of being bullies in school and engaging in harmful practices like drug, alcohol, and sexual abuse. A lot of careers have been stalled because of allegations coming from nowhere and unfortunately, days before their 10th anniversary, the name of Apink’s leader Chorong suddenly came up.
050121— on this day last year, naeun posted this on her ig 😭💕 always apink ot6. pic.twitter.com/EZn6Rl8vVM
Reports of Chorong engaging in underage drinking and bullying sprang up on April 5, 14 days short of Apink’s 10th anniversary. To keep the rather long story short, Person A, a female schoolmate of Chorong, posted pictures of her drinking in 2008, back when she was only 17-years-old. The person claimed that Chorong would go out drinking with friends every week and would figure in acts of physical violence targeting unpopular classmates. Days later, Chorong made a statement apologizing for the pictures of her drinking alcohol, which meant that she admitted to the underage alcohol consumption while denying the bullying claims. Play M Entertainment supported their talent and filed legal cases against the person. Months later, a classmate who knew both Chorong and A claimed that the two were actually bosom buddies during their high school years and had a falling out later, although she did not realize that the person would dig up the issue 13 years later. In November, police investigations concluded that the allegations against Chorong were false.
Unfortunately, the damage has been done as the comeback to mark Apink’s 10th anniversary kept getting pushed back. To commemorate their anniversary, the group only released Thank You, their annual song for their fans. Moreover, Play M announced ten days after the group’s anniversary that Naeun has decided to not re-sign her contract with them. Days later, Naeun revealed that she has signed with YG Entertainment as an actress and will still remain as a member of Apink.
Wait, what? Naeun, the most reserved member of Apink has signed with the entertainment agency known for their swag and talents who are more known for their big personalities? Before contemplating on how Naeun’s move to YG was just plain weird, consider these:
Naeun signed to YG as an actress and SPOILER: up to now, has not shown any indication of transferring her singing career to her new agency;
Naeun’s sister, Son Saeun, a professional golfer, has been a YG Sports talent since 2017.
Considering those two things, it does make sense for Apink’s visual to choose YG as her new agency after A CubePlan APlay M IST Entertainment. But then, considering that Naeun was already accepting acting gigs even when she was still with A CubePlan APlay M IST, was the transfer really necessary? Did Chorong’s scandal have anything to do with Naeun opting to sign with a different agency? When you look at the events, we can conclude that the leader’s bullying scandal may be a factor, albeit a minor one.
A few years ago, in their first contract renewal with A CubePlan APlay M IST, it was revealed by the members that all of them re-signed with the agency without delays or hesitation because of Chorong. In interviews, when Apink members were asked how they were able to successfully overcome the 7-year curse that affects k-pop idol groups, they would usually narrate how Chorong, as a leader, assured them to leave things to her and trust her as re-signing with their agency would be the best move for all six of them. With the bullying scandal at its peak in April 2021, precisely during the time when the members were working out and negotiating the terms of their contracts, Chorong may have lost a lot of her bargaining leverage, prompting Naeun to heavily consider transferring agencies. But then, it wouldn’t be totally a reach if Naeun just decided that she was tired of having to share her income with five other people, which is the common practice among idol groups. With a new agency, she gets to have all the proceeds of her income to herself instead of always having to split in six-ways.
Fast forward to December 2021, when A CubePlan APlay M IST Entertainment announced the return of Apink! The group will have a comeback scheduled for February 2022 with the participation of all six members. Pandas rejoice!
With the Chorong controversy finally meeting its end in November, you would think A CubePlan APlay M IST would schedule the Apink’s comeback / 10th year anniversary celebration ASAP. In an ideal scenario, then comeback schedules can be implemented easily and the Apink anniversary comeback could have happened in December. Capitalize on the Chorong redemption arc – support a wrongly accused idol on her comeback that will celebrate her 10th year in the music industry, why not? But then, when A CubePlan APlay M IST has to deal with YG, things can get complicated. YG can always say Naeun has drama 1, drama 2, and drama 3 on her plate, so participating in the making and promotion of the comeback album may not be a priority. True, Naeun was (going to be) busy with Ghost Doctor and Apink anniversary events (i.e. fan meets and concerts like Pink Eve: 10 Years, which did happen on December 31 and may have already been repeatedly rescheduled), but then Eunji was also busy with Work Later, Drink Now, so… yep, it is really difficult to coordinate schedules when another company is involved.
this apink gif always gets me… the way they’re all doing their own thing and chorong gathers all of them one by one like 🐣 to make sure they’re focusing… i’ll never move on pic.twitter.com/573FjiCMI2
Which brings us to Horn, Apink’s latest comeback released on Valentine’s Day 2022. All six members are part of the album and the music video. Unfortunately, YG put its foot down and did not allow Naeun to join the promotions of the lead track, Dilemma. The five remaining members did the usual round of music, radio, and variety show promotions. Naeun has posted on Instagram of her support for her bandmates, but alas, when you have the five posting pictures of their music show guest stints and Naeun posting pictures of a Winter Olympics event she is watching on TV, people can (and have) start questioning her sincerity.
Naeun has been vilified, YG has been painted as the antagonist, with reports surfacing that the company actually encouraged Naeun to leave Apink once they successfully signed her. Naeun shut down the possibility as she reportedly said something along the lines of her not ever considering leaving the group that was responsible for establishing her name in the entertainment industry. We cannot really blame Chorong for the series of unfortunate events she had to undergo as the cause of the delays in the comeback and maybe being a factor in Naeun leaving A CubePlan APlay M IST. I think it makes the most sense to just blame YG for anything and everything; they’re used to being vilified, anyway.
After three years, Mnet’s girl group competition—Queendom—is back with a new set of groups who will try to follow MAMAMOO’s footsteps. After much anticipation, Mnet released the Queendom Season 2 lineup last February 21 and of course, there’s a lot of fun prior to the show in guessing how the results will be. Based on the six Kpop girl group contestants, who will emerge on top?
Thus, we shall go through the six participating groups in alphabetical order. You can’t really go wrong with an alphabetically-arranged list to dispel any explanations of bias, eh?
Here’s the full Queendom Season 2 lineup:
Brave Girls
The pros: Yes, they need the boost that the show Queendom 2 will bring so that they can further stretch the 15 minutes of fame the viral video brought them. Their discography is something most of the rest of the girls (definitely with the exception of Hyolyn and her SISTAR connection – a definite gold standard in girl group discographies) can only dream of. I mean, High Heels? Deepened? Yoo-hoo? Those were ABSOLUTE BANGERS. The songs only girl groups can dream of as being part of their musical history. Well, come to think of it, they are the BRAVE GIRLS, the first girl group under the label of THE BRAVE BROTHERS, only legendary k-pop producers responsible for the breathtaking discographies of iconic groups such as After School. T-ara, and 4Minute, to name a few. So, when it comes to songs the group can use to battle with the other contestants, they don’t and won’t have problems with that.
Discography – check. Performance factor – check. Who can ever doubt the skills of these girls who have danced on top of chairs and performed that stingray move super seriously (like don’t they find that Name recall – check. The newfound fame—that compilation video of them performing for the military—lifted them to phenomenal status. And at a time when they achieved newfound fame when everyone was at their homes during lockdown only added to their fame because people didn’t really have much else to do – even those who don’t follow a lot of k-pop didn’t have much of a choice but see them go viral on social media and mainstream entertainment. So yes, Koreans (or at least those who will be watching Queendom) by now know who the Brave Girls are. Bye, nugu-dom; hello, Queendom 2!
The cons: The line-up. The group’s discography (and the songs of the other competing groups, especially WJSN) has a lot of rap verses that were fire under the very able skills of main rapper Hyeran. Unfortunately, Hyeran has been inactive with the group since 2017 and was officially out of it by 2019. The current 4-member line-up – Minyeong, Eunji, Yuna, and Yunjeong are pretty much solid when it comes to vocal skills. Minyeong can belt high notes like nobody’s business and the vocals of the three others can surely make Brave Brothers proud, but Eunji and Yuna as the designated rappers, cannot really measure up to the original main rapper’s skill level. So, yes, I did say that the current BG line-up is a bit unbalanced.
Given the other groups in the competition, I am thinking that Brave Girls will pull off an AOA and will most likely end up 4th or in the worst-case scenario, 5th.
Cosmic Girls
When it comes to looking for an ideal girl group participant for an Mnet reality show, the Cosmic Girls would fit the bill. The lineup is spectacular, as even without the fantastic Chinese trio whose presence has not been felt by the group since 2018, the group still looks balanced and in fighting form in all aspects. We have to admit, Xuanyi, Chengxiao, and Meiqi were practically the group’s main dancers and international crowd drawers (read: visuals to reiterate the group’s diversity), and all these contributions have been ably filled up by Bona and Seola, plus formerly overlooked members Yeoreum and Eunseo. That the group has such a huge lineup may have worked against them in the past, as it used to be that the public’s attention span seems to be limited to nine members at most (thank you, Girl’s Generation) and WJSN’s delineation of the member’s skills isn’t as pronounced as another huge group with so many members, SEVENTEEN. The way Pledis made the three groupings – vocal, performance, and hip-hop very distinct for SEVENTEEN worked for them, as the public caught on immediately and associated even the members who are less popular with their units (e.g., Dino is a performer, Joshua is a vocalist). The units for WJSN – Wonder, Joy, Natural, and Sweet didn’t really work that well for WJSN. But after the three Chinese members’ hiatus from the group, the lesser-known members like Luda, Yeoreum, and Eunso had some space to step up and get themselves some recognition. Thus, everything – Bona, Seola, and Yeoreum in charge of visuals and dance; Eunseo, Exy, and Luda in charge of rap and dance; and Soobin, Dayoung,
Dawon, and Yeonjung in charge of vocals (these four are quite a superior vocal line), make the current WJSN lineup simply spectacular.
As for their discography, WJSN also has a very credible stable of songs that can match the competition. After all, they are a Starship group, and with SISTAR and Monsta X as solid proof, WJSN has been blessed with some really good songs since their debut in 2016. They have also proven themselves to be very versatile and adaptive when it comes to concept and image tweaks as they successfully went from very cutesy in their Mo Mo Mo debut to more sophisticated in Catch Me, before going mystical and dream-like in Secret with Yeonjung’s entry into the group. The group has gone on to oscillate between girly (Happy, Boogie Up) and darker (Dreams Come True, Unnatural) concepts, although always maintaining that mystical and cosmic ingredient to their comebacks. They have even scored a hit that has someone ingrained itself into Korean contemporary culture, as their 2019 song As You Wish makes an annual return to the top of the charts every New Year for three years in the running – 2020, 2021, and 2022!
WJSN sells well and has household name status, but I don’t believe the group will win Queendom season 2. I do have a feeling they will be the Oh My Girls of this season, massively reaping the rewards of the show after it ends. Best case, they will get second, and at worst, they will be 4th. I don’t see them faring very bad at all, but I also don’t see them winning the whole thing owing to the other participants having larger fanbases. I will be quite happy if they end up winning though.
Hyolyn
Speaking of Starship Entertainment, now we have a member of one of the most, if not the most successful group Starship has produced so far, Hyolyn of the iconic Kpop girl group SISTAR. SISTAR is one of those groups that didn’t even encounter rookie difficulties and went on to release hit after hit (with a sterling record of having all their title tracks at #1 in Gaon) until their unfortunate disbandment in 2017. And if Hyolyn will be fully reliant on the SISTAR catalog, there’s no question she’ll do awfully well in the competition. For one, SISTAR continues to have good name recall with the Korean public. The group parted ways with not much controversy, as they even did a farewell tour of all the music shows, both to promote what was going to be their last single, Lonely, and perform medlies of their greatest hits as a sort of encore performance. Plus, there’s no denying that SISTAR songs are just great songs.
This brings us to how Hyolyn’s trajectory in the show might end up being similar to the only solo act that has appeared in the show so far (considering both Queendom and the male version Kingdom), 2NE1’s Bom. Unfortunately, Bom did not do well during the show, always finishing 5th or 6th in the rankings. While Bom was constantly lauded for her bravery to join a contest where she has to compete by herself against groups, she somehow always sounded shaky in her performances, not to mention people still felt uncomfortable with how her facial features have changed. Suffice to say that people still recognize Bom as a solid vocalist as her solo releases have been warmly received, but her live performances have somehow a negative effect on viewers. Simply put, watching Bom live makes people anxious.
On the other hand, the opposite can be said of Hyolyn. People somehow already know what to expect from a Hyolyn live performance: stable vocals and risque portions. Seriously, were people really shocked with her performance in the 2018 KBS Drama Awards? She was going to perform Dally, and Dally is pretty much a “trademark” Hyolyn song – vocally challenging but easily unnoticeable because people would tend to focus on the rather suggestive choreography. So, if Queendom is set on showing performances that will send tounges a-wagging for weeks for a bit of “shock factor”, then they can most definitely count on the former SISTAR leader for that.
What Hyolyn lacks is a credible solo discography.
While Bom’s post-2NE1 releases have relatively good critical and commercial reception, Hyolyn’s has been a bit erratic. Although we know her as this sexy performer, Hyolyn’s most commercially successful releases have actually been OSTs – Goodbye from My Love from a Star and Let it Go from Frozen, to name a few. Her solo releases when she was still with Starship charted well, but after See Sea, Dally, and Bae, her releases under her own record label have not achieved similar levels of popularity. Thus, to perform well in the show, Hyolyn may have to really rely on the SISTAR (and SISTAR19 – Gone Not Around Any Longer and Ma Boy are still very much popular) catalog and her earlier works.
Having said that, I think if Hyolyn plays her cards right, she can rank as high as 3rd. Unfortunately, if she catches the Park Bom “curse” of solo performers not faring that well in Queendom, then there’s a possibility she’ll finish at the bottom.
But of course, everybody will still be looking forward to a 2022 version of Dally.
Kep1er
Not a lot can be said of Kep1er. That’s because the group was only formed months ago and only debuted in January.
So, yes, what really can be said about the group that has had only one song under their belts? One thing’s for sure: Kep1er does feel like a last-minute addition to the show, the type of group that was only included in the line-up because a group backed out before the final announcement was made. Rumors were rife that Apink would be this edition’s MAMAMOO (aka a veteran group that had many ask, why are they on this show?), as well as Dreamcatcher. Now that either group is in the final line-up, many have concluded that Kep1er filled in for either group as it is likely that Apink did not want to do the show without Naeun (who YG will never permit to appear on such a show, although they did allow iKON to appear in Kingdom, which also had many scratching their heads) and Happyface does not see the merits of allowing Dreamcatcher to join the show (or any Mnet show). It is also likely that Mnet just wants to mindlessly push (read: shove) Kep1er down everybody’s throats since the show they produced for their formation, Girls Planet 999, unfortunately, did not turn out as successfully as its Produce predecessors. From Mnet’s viewpoint, they might as well ensure a return on their investment with every opportunity they get, eh?
Swing Music, the group’s current label, may have also warmed to the idea that any exposure Kep1er gets will be beneficial to the group, no matter if it makes them look miscast or like fish out of wonder because they’re competing against some tried and tested performers. So, maybe the goal of Kep1er’s participation in the show isn’t really to win the whole thing but just to keep the group in the public’s consciousness. Also, since Kep1er just finished competing months ago, the members might still be in competition mode even as we’re speaking, so that “rookie mindset” may work for them in the show.
On the other hand, their inexperience in going up against industry veterans and their general state of being too “green” and amateur may also work against them. Besides, they don’t even have a discography. Alas, not a lot of people have warmed up to a number of Kep1er’s members, particularly the much-maligned Huening Bahiyyih. IOI had Sohye, IZ*ONE had Kang Hyewon, and now, there is, unfortunately, a lot of hate for Huening Bahiyyih. IOI and IZ*ONE didn’t compete again, though, so the amount of vitriol the poor German-Brazilian-Korean idol will be subject to is still unknown. But then again, shall we count on MOA to rally behind Huening Bahiyyih again? Lest we forget that fans of her brother, Huening Kai, were attributed in ensuring Bahiyyih’s spot in Kep1er by power voting in the finals, despite her lackluster performances in Girls Planet 999. Based on their WA DA DA stages, I think Kep1er will do fine in terms of performances, and since they have a member who is the sister of one of k-pop’s most popular groups, that can only work in her and her groups’ favor.
LOONA
Much has been said about LOONA, and if the show will allow worldwide voting, then, as early as now, we can safely say that LOONA will win Queendom 2. No need for performances, no need for drama, no need for challenges, leave it to the Orbits to ensure victory for LOONA and the LOONAVERSE.
Queendom is an Mnet show. Mnet has a history of vote manipulation in reality shows. Kep1er is practically an Mnet creation. Mnet may most likely do anything to turn things towards Kep1er’s favor. In other words, international Orbits may most likely be silenced.
This may definitely work against LOONA as compared to the Brave Girls, Hyolyn, WJSN, and VIVIZ (or at least its members), LOONA’s popularity in Korea hasn’t matched the groups mentioned. If Mnet insists on Korea-only voting rules (just like they had in the Produce seasons after the first one – yes, the manipulated seasons), then the playing field (or at least the voting demographics) may be more even for all groups.
Because in terms of line-up and performance, LOONA as a whole unit may not be as good as the others. LOONA and WJSN may have started off at the same time, but the latter already performed as a whole group with Yeonjung since August 2016. LOONA finally performed as a group of twelve in 2018. That’s a two-year headstart for WJSN to work on and improve their group dynamics and harmony. Even Hyolyn has had a year of getting used to performing solo before LOONA released Hi High.
Finally, it has to be said: the strength of LOONA as a group is weaker than the strength of its individual members. The releases of each member are definitely more interesting than the group’s releases. From Hi High to PTT (Paint the Town), fans have been anticipating for a breakthrough, that one release that will push the group into explosive heights of popularity. And that anticipation has been on for four years and running.
So, will LOONA dominate Queendom? If international voting will be allowed, then yes, by a landslide. If dominating the show will be based on Korean following, performances, and discography, LOONA might be this season’s Lovelyz or AOA.
VIVIZ
Finally, we have tricky VIVIZ. Several factors will definitely have an effect on how VIVZ will fare on the show.
The use of GFriend’s discography. This will definitely give VIVIZ a huge advantage. The thought of Rough, Navillera, and Sunrise alone is already giving me chills.
That the GFriend discography will be performed with SinB is gold. But the intricacies of GFriend choreo to be reduced to being performed by a trio may prove to be a little underwhelming. It’s like Oh My girl choreography being down to YooA and Mimi. The girls will definitely still have the moves, but the grandness of the formations and changes will, unfortunately, be lost.
That the GFriend discography will be sung without Sowon and Yuju will definitely be very tricky. It will be a huge challenge for Eunha and Umji to fill in the shoes of the two main vocals. Song arrangement will play a vital role. It goes without saying Hyolyn will have a walk in the park. Yeonjung, Dawon, Dayoung, and Soobin will not have any problems with that. Chuu and HaSeul should step up to the plate. Yeseo and Youngeun may match Sowon and Yuju’s levels for Kep1er. But Eunha and Umji… it’s gonna be challenging.
Can VIVIZ count on Buddy’s voting power to tide them through the competition? That remains to be seen. If the performance of the group’s first EP is any indication, then we may expect good results, but even LOONA’s Korean Orbits may pose a challenge.
But let’s get one thing clear: Queendom still boils down to voting. So, if the show comes down to votes, we can look forward to these results:
Korea-only votes will be considered:
Kep1er
WJSN
Brave Girls
VIVIZ
LOONA
Hyolyn
International votes + Korea votes combined:
1. LOONA
.
.
.
.
.
2. A mad scramble
But of course, the show will still be fun because of Mnet edits, the performances, and the drama! Personally, I am looking forward to these things:
A couple of girls may complain that Hyolyn may have featured artists in her performances (reminiscent of Jimin complaining of Bom having people with her).
LOONA performing WJSN’s Butterfly and WJSN performing LOONA’s Butterfly
WJSN performing SISTAR songs for the nth time (I can only reckon they’ve been performing them since trainee years) but with a lot of embellishments for the show
Kep1er getting a chance to perform any and all songs originally performed by their competition
Kep1er’s Xiaoting performing Chinese line portions of WJSN songs
Hyolyn performing Brave Girls’ sexier hits (Hyolyn performing High Heels!!!)
Brave Girls performing Dally (the only choreography that can compete with their stingray move)
Umji performing Dally
GFriend choreography being performed by LOONA
Taeyeon – Hyolyn legendary main vocal interaction
If the Queendom Season 2 lineup is not exciting, we don’t know what is. Can’t wait to see how the competition unfolds and which Kpop girl group wins!
Featured image: Mamamoo won the first season of Queendom in 2019. Photo: Mnet K-POP/YouTube.
The recently concluded finals of the idol survival show Girls Planet 999, which included contestants from Korea, Japan, and Chinese territories (China, Taiwan, and Hong Kong), has the public wondering again if Chinese idols don’t get a fair break among K-fans. Throughout the show, at least 2 or 3 Chinese contestants figure in the top 9 contestants of the show, which by its end, will compose a nine-member girl group. One of the Chinese contestants, Shen Xiaaoting, was ranked number 1 in three of the five episodes that have the contestant’s rankings revealed. And on the final episode, she ended up 9th.
With the Korean public becoming a tad weary of Chinese idols for a good number of reasons, such as the government implementing stricter guidelines towards idols and fans – from discouraging “sissy” idols to spending excessive amounts of money on voting in idol survival shows (which may also be a reason the Chinese girls ended up not performing well in Girls Planet 999) to several Chinese idols making highly patriotic political stands (e.g. Jackson Wang siding with the government on the Xinjiang cotton issue), fans of groups with Chinese members are crossing their fingers on the plight of their idols. Let’s have a look at three different cases of Chinese members of some K-pop groups.
Chinese K-pop Members on Top: The Case of Jun and The8
Perhaps, the most active Chinese idols in the K-pop industry are Jun and The8 of the 13-member group SEVENTEEN. Jun (who was born in Shenzhen, China) and The8 (a native of Anshan, China) have not been able to have a homecoming until last October. As the group debuted in 2015, Jun and The8 have not returned to China ever since, until recently, which means they haven’t been with friends and family for more than six years. Even the pandemic did not stop the two from continuously staying in Korea for the group’s last four comebacks in Korea – Hengarae (with the lead single Left and Right), Semicolon (with the lead single Home;Run), Your Choice (with the lead single Ready to Love), and Attacca (with the lead single Rock With You). The group has also had three Japanese comebacks since the pandemic started – Fallin’ Flower in April 2020, 24H in September 2020, and Not Alone in April 2021. All three releases have topped the Japanese Oricon charts, despite the group not actually holding in-person live events in the country due to COVID-19.
For the latest comeback, the two Chinese members were part of the recording of the entire EP and making the music videos. This means that they have versions of the songs with 13-person choreography and 11-person choreography. It has been a tad unfortunate though that when the EP Attacca was released on October 22, the two members are back in China. Both are still quite active in promoting the song on their social media accounts, though, and have also uploaded videos on the group’s TikTok account of them dancing to the “killing parts” of their single Rock With You. According to Pledis Entertainment, the two boys will be back in Korea in the New Year, which may most probably mean after the Chinese celebrations of Lunar New Year.
Judging from June and The8’s social media posts, there’s little to no reason why CARATs have to be worried about them and their status with SEVENTEEN. Besides, all thirteen members, including Jun and The8, renewed their contracts with Pledis, which is now under HYBE (aka BTS’ company) a year ahead of their expiration. It seems that the commitment of all members to the group is quite strong.
The Curious Case of the Chinese Members of WJSN
Here’s a story of another 13-member group: the Cosmic Girls or WJSN. From the group’s formation in 2016, the Chinese presence in the then-12-member group has been established, with Xuanyi, Meiqi, and Cheng Xiao holding prominent positions in the group. All of WJSN’s title tracks have been released in China and even have Mandarin versions. The three members were also present when the group welcomed a new member to their fold – Produce 101 alumna Yeonjung in late 2016, when her project group I.O.I allowed some of its members to join groups of their agencies.
Things went a bit awkward when the three Chinese members suddenly grabbed opportunities in their native China all at the same time while still promoting with the group. Fresh from the promotions of their latest EP Dream Your Dream (with the lead single Dreams Come True) from late February to mid-March of 2018, Meiqi and Xuanyi were pulled out from group promotions to compete in the first season of Produce 101 China. On the other hand, as early as January, Cheng Xiao went back and forth between China and Korea, as she was appointed as a dance mentor in the male idol group formation show Idol Producer. Fun fact: Cheng Xiao’s fellow coaches included EXO’s Lay, then GOT7’s Jackson, and then Pristin’s Kulkyung who were in various stages of activity/inactivity with their respective groups.
Meiqi and Xuanyi did well in Produce 101 China, so well that they were actually the two top-ranked contestants of the show. Due to their ranking, they automatically became members of the show’s project girl group, Rocket Girls 101. For her part, Cheng Xiao accepted acting jobs in China and did not return to Korea to reunite her group and participate in their next comeback, WJ Please, which had the lead single Save Me, Save You.
What happened to the two Rocket Girls? On August 9, Yuehua Entertainment (Starship’s partner in WJSN) and Mavericks Entertainment released a joint announcement stating that they would be withdrawing Meiqi and Xianyi, along with Mavericks talent Zhang Zining (who placed 7th in the show) from Rocket Girls. However, a week later, both companies confirmed that after coming to an agreement with Tencent (Rocket Girls 101’s company), that Meiqi, Xuanyi, and Zining will be returning to the group.
The Cosmic Girls continued to promote all throughout 2019, releasing three EPs. During this time, Meiqi and Xuanyi continued to promote with their new group Rocket Girls 101 while accepting acting and TV appearance jobs. While still promoting with her Chinese group, Meiqi released her debut EP in April 2019, which subsequently sold more than 2.5 million copies. Xuanyi also got casted in Chinese variety shows even during her time as a Rocket Girl. Cheng Xiao also continued appearing in C-dramas and variety shows.
Rocket Girls 101 disbanded in 2020, yet the two (plus Cheng Xiao) have not returned to promoting with Cosmic Girls. With a ton of activities in China, the three are not expected to reunite with their WJSN groupmates anytime soon. For their part, WJSN have had two successful comebacks despite the pandemic, with their two EPS, Neverland and Unnatural, selling more than 105,000 and 92,000 copies, respectively.
Chinese members of Cube’s Groups: CLC, Pentagon, and (G)I-dle
Three of Cube Entertainment’s groups have Chinese members – Elkie from Hong Kong, Yan’An from Shanghai (though born in Japan), and Yuqi from Beijing. There’s not a lot of weird activity solely happening with the three, with their careers taking rollercoaster rides because of the company’s (mis)management of their groups.
Let’s start with Elkie who’s supposed to be from the most senior of the three groups, CLC. Unfortunately, despite their “seniority”, it seemed that Cube had always been weird towards its treatment of the group. CLC was a sort of bridesmaid to 4Minute, which until their disbandment in 2016, was Cube’s leading girl group. When the group finally disbanded, the company showed their efforts in “prioritizing” CLC by adding two new members – Elkie who was then already a popular TV personality in Hong Kong, and Eunbin, who was at that time fresh from her stint in Produce 101 (eliminated in the second to the last episode). CLC showed promise with their High Heels Japanese comeback and their Hobgoblin Korean comeback, the latter featuring an image change for the group that showed them sporting an edgier concept resembling that of the then-recently-disbanded 4Minute.
The group felt like they were on their way to finally break through the local market when something weird happened – the company debuted a new group, (G)I-dle, which includes another Produce 101 alumna, Soyeon, and Chinese member Yuqi. The public instantly warmed up to (G)I-dle’s girl crush image with a slight softness. So, it seemed like CLC skidded a bit to the sidelines yet again.
For the part of Pentagon, they went the normal boy group career trajectory, as, during their debut in 2016, Cube was still holding a bit of hope for their “Legacy” group, BEAST, while now putting more effort into the promotions of their second boy group in line, BTOB. Things took an unexpected turn for the better when the group’s song, Shine from ther sixth Korean EP POsitive became a sleeper hit, thanks to positive word of mouth from listeners who got hooked with the group’s trendy choreography and the song’s earworm quality. The song started out in the Gaon charts in the 500s, then rose by hundreds of places until it peaked at number 27. It did feel like the group was finally on its way to attaining superior-level boy group levels of fame.
Then Yan’An got sick, making him take a health break from the group. Also, E’Dawn was revealed to have a relationship with Cube’s biggest stars, former 4Minute center HyunA. At first, the company denied this, then the two actually admitted to the relationship, after which the company dropped her and E’Dawn. Yan’An took another health break (a longer one this time for most of 2020). Members Junho and leader Hui (who was also in a group with HyunA and E’Dawen called Triple H) are currently on military duty, so the group is practically on that weird state exclusively occurring among boy groups: a hiatus with awkward and poorly promoted releases by still-active members. Yan’An is back with the group, but with its weird status, we’re not exactly sure what the future holds for the group.
This brings us back to CLC and (G)I-dle. With the company obviously preferring the newer group, CLC was pushed back and forth from sweet and innocent songs to edgy girl crush releases, while (G)I-dle getting better songs.
Their latest/last release was Helicopter in August 2020 and before the year ended, Elkie sent a legal notice to Cube Entertainment requesting termination of her contract, citing that she has not received payment for her acting activities and that Cube Entertainment had already stopped their “developmental support” of CLC, putting the group in an uncertain future. On February 3, 2021, Cube Entertainment confirmed that Elkie is not with the group anymore and her contract has been terminated. Fast forward to September, when member Yujin, who joined Girls Planet 999, said in an interview on the show that the group has been “dismissed.” As fans, we can only interpret this as CLC disbanding.
Finally, what has happened to the rather successful (G)I-dle? With EPs that sell more than 200,000 copies (AMAZING considering 100,000 units sold for girl groups is already a lot) and all lead singles charting notably high (the group’s last single, Hwaa, peaked at #4), the three-year-old group has achieved top-tier status in record time. Considering they’re not from SM, JYP, or YG, their sales and chart performances are unquestionably commendable. They even won new fans when they participated and eventually placed third in the idol group competition Queendom, only placing behind MAMAMOO and Oh My Girl. everything is turning up roses for (G)I-dle until something gets messed up.
Only several weeks after the promotions ended for the group’s latest release, Hwaa, Cube announced that Soojin would temporarily halt all activities after bullying accusations by former classmates rose. The company has since encouraged individual activities, with Yuqi releasing her first EP as a solo artist, A Page, in May and Soyeon releasing her solo EP, Windy, the following month.
Finally, on August 14, Cube Entertainment announced that Soojin has departed from the group. (G)I-dle is now down to five members, but there hasn’t been news about a comeback. Several weird developments have happened since Soojin’s departure from the group, with various reports claiming that the members did not agree to Soojin getting booted out of the group and have become disappointed with Cube. Many also pointed out the lackluster support the company gave to Yuqi’s debut.
Finally, only days after the announcement of Soojin’s departure, rumors of Soyeon leaving Cube and therefore, the group spread like wildfire. On August 28, Soyeon hello a vLive session and eagle-eyed watchers were quick to point out that there was something tucked in her phone case – a business card with the logo of PNation, Psy’s relatively new entertainment agency that houses, surprise, surprise – the banished duo of HyunA and E’Dawn! That it has been months since the last comeback and the year is drawing to a close, fans can’t help but wonder if it is also “buh-bye Cube” time for (G)I-dle.
So, there you have it- the great, the mysterious, and the perennial mistreatment among Chinese idols. Let’s hope there’ll be more Juns and The8’s in the future of K-pop.
Featured image: [Special Video] SVT JUN&THE8 ‘MY I’ KOR ver. Photo: SEVENTEEN/YouTube
Has the Netflix hit Squid Gamehave you pining for more Korean shows where people play games for money? Don’t worry, there has been quite a number of Korean game shows that have been produced that had contestants compete for money, just like in Squid Game. The good thing is, the contestants in these shows don’t have to resort to violence and death.
The show we’re going to explore is The Genius, a game show that ran for four seasons, from 2013 to 2015. When it was aired, it became a huge fad in Korea.
The Genius was a reality game show with 13 contestants from different backgrounds. There are some celebrities known for their social skills, professionals known for their particular skills in their work, and finally some “regular folk” known for their exceptional intelligence. These participants compete to be on top in every episode, which provides them with immunity from elimination. On every episode, one contestant is eliminated after two rounds of games – a Main Match and a Death Match.
During the Main Match, all players who have survived the previous episode’s elimination will play to win and to be immune from elimination via a token of life. There have been some Main Matches where more than one contestant receives the token of life and therefore, is exempted from elimination. In Main Matches, the winner receives an additional token of life which they can give to a fellow contestant, sparing the recipient from elimination as well.
The contestant who performed the worst in the Main Match will face off with an opponent of his or her own choosing from among the contestants without a token of life in the Death Match. There have been episodes where there are joint losers, in which case the winner(s) of the Main Match will have to nominate the Death Match player from among the losers. Obviously, the Death Match loser is the eliminated contestant of that episode.
Today #GoingSeventeen feels like old Korean reality game show #TheGenius with all the mind gaming. If you want this kind of content you can watch The Genius. The mind gaming is serious like if it's still running Jeonghan will win there. pic.twitter.com/cIzDbxx0SM
Aside from the token of life, the winner(s) of the Main Match also win a number of red garnets. A red garnet is equivalent to 1,000,000 won (approximately US$1,000). In the final episode, only the total garnets of the winning contestant are exchanged for his or her prize money. Throughout the show, garnets can be given to other contestants as a form of leverage when negotiating some aspects of the game. Some Main Matches also allow the use of garnets for clues or implements that may win a game for a contestant.
As the show’s title denotes, it would take a genius to win – but not just a genius in the conventional definition of being someone who has superior academic intelligence. As the start of the third season’s first episode showed, there are different kinds of intelligence, according to Harvard psychologist Howard Garner. To win this game show, it is believed that the contestant needs to employ the kind of intelligence that would benefit him or her the most, at least for a particular Main Match or Death Match. It can be interpersonal intelligence, verbal-linguistic intelligence, logical-mathematical intelligence, etc.
The key is for the contestant to realize what skills are important for a victory. Thus, having a high IQ may not be assurance of success in the show, as understanding and grasping concepts quickly also aren’t – other contestants may notice this skill and may consider you a threat, prompting them to ally with other contestants to plot your downfall. Some watches may require more of quick scheming, others may require superior logic, yet others may demand alliances and betrayal.
What are the games played in the Main and Death Matches?
Most, if not all games are made to look like contestants need to be astute in using logic and mathematical skills, but that might only get them so far. A good deal of one’s success in the games also involves strategy and negotiations and building cooperative relationships and alliances with co-players to ensure favorable outcomes. Outthinking and amazing strategic mindsets can also help a lot in giving a contestant a win.
For example, in Season 2, Episode 11, TV personality and politician Yoo Junghyun faced comedian Noh Hongchul in the Death Match that required them to play Same Picture Hunt, a game that was also Season 1’s final Death Match. The game involves 16 picture tiles hidden behind 16 letter panels and arranged in a 4 by 4 board for the contestants’ reference. Tiles corresponding to the pictures are then dealt out on a conveyor belt with 20 spaces on it. The candidates then try to locate the picture on the board that matches the next tile on their belt. If correct, they move to the next tile, their conveyor belt not moving. But if they’re wrong, the belt is sent one space backward and the erring contestant loses their turn. This continues until either the winning candidate reaches the end of their conveyor belt or until the losing candidate loses all his or her tiles because they have fallen off the belt.
Seems to be your usual memory game, right? In Season 1, former idol and TV personality Lee Sangmin and former newscaster and TV personality Kim Kyungran played the game in a straight laced-fashion – a battle of memory. That did not happen in Season 2 as politician Jonghyun used his advantage of going second in the game to block out Hongchul. How?
For example, Hongchul wanted to know the picture behind the letter S. As Hongchul’s picture and the picture behind S do not match, it becomes Jonghyun’s turn. Jonghyun does not use his turn to discover what’s behind another letter and instead just repeats Honghul’s chosen letter, S, for his round. Thus, Hongchul is not given new information. Since he comes first in the game, he used up all his tiles before Jonghyun lost his. Smart, eh?
Another popular Death Match that was frequently used in Season 1 was Winning Streak, or simply put, rock paper scissors with politics. The point of the game is to make sure you have more allies with your fellow contestants compared to your opponent, so that you will have a longer winning streak, as you will play rock paper scissors with the contestants who aren’t in the elimination block. If the contestants you have allied with are few and far from each other, then the chances of you getting a long winning streak is slim.
A lot of games were like this, proving that while you can get ahead in the contest with just a thorough understanding of the game’s rules, being strategic on how to use this understanding to win the game is also important.
Who were the players in The Genius?
The Genius ran for four seasons and had popular personalities as contestants. In Season 1, aside from Sangmin and Kyungran who were mentioned earlier, other contestants include former member of the short-lived girl group Tinus Choi Jungmoon (who also happens to be a MENSA member, eliminated in Episode 5), controversial MC and DJ Kim Gura (as in the grouchy panelist in Radio Star and King of Masked Singer, eliminated in Episode 6), INFINITE leader Sunggyu (who was actually quite successful, reaching Episode 10 before getting eliminated), webtoon artist Kim Poong (eliminated in Episode 7), and weather reporter Park Eunji (eliminated in Episode 9). The season was won by former professional Starcraft player and TV personality Hong Jinho, who faced off with Kyungran in the final episode.
i've been saying this for years but the genius is simply just peak game show, i just keep coming back to it years after because i'm apparently not as smart as i think i am and every challenge is like a fresh challenge again for me to re-figure out 😂
Season 1 champ Jinho (who was unfortunately eliminated in Episode 7) and Sangmin returned in Season 2. Aside from Hongchul and Jonghyun mentioned earlier, they were joined by Jaekyung (leader of girl group RAINBOW, 2nd to be eliminated). Jiwon (as in the leader of 1st gen mega group Sechs Kies, who like Season 1’s Sunggyu was also eliminated in Episode 10), magician Lee Eungyeol (who was always in coattails and sunglasses throughout the show, 4th to be eliminated), and former Starcraft professional player Lim Yohwan (as in Jinho’s mortal adversary in the gaming world), who faced Sangmin in the finals.
Season 3 included academy math teacher and KAIST lecturer Nam Hweejung (who rose to fame after becoming the first contestant eliminated in Season 2 as many disliked his arrogance, though he fared better in Season 3, where he got eliminated in Episode 4), former singer and actor Kim Jeonghoon (as in Prince Lee Yul in Princess Hours, eliminated in Episode 6), and eventual winner, comedian Jang Dongmin, who beat then 19-year-old KAIST student Oh Hyunmin. Hyunmin, who then was the youngest contestant to ever appear in the show’s four seasons, went on to become a TV personality.
Season 4 is sort of the show’s “greatest hits” season, where the most popular players of all three seasons reunited.
What was the best season?
The answer to this question really depends on the viewer’s personal preference. I personally prefer Season 1 the most, since the contestants were pretty much left to their open devices on how to play the games and strategize, while the two other seasons already have references from previous seasons and thus, came more prepared.
Season 1 set the bar with the brilliance of the eventual winner, Jinho, whom showed amazing performances in the three Death Matches he participated in and won, as well as winning three Main Matches as well. How he played the games and avoided betrayal as much as possible was also remarkable. The season also showed fantastic runs from Sunggyu, who led on other players by pretending he was mostly clueless of the games to hide his brilliance in tactical thinking and Kyungran, who managed to always be in the right place and the right time and thus, avoiding Death Matches (she only played one Death Match – the last one before the final episode).
Jiwon on another strategy game show? Kinda makes me want to finish S2 and S4 of The Genius… I stopped watching when Hong Jinho lost lol
Season 2 was a bit of a damper in the sense that most of the season was spent on something that wasn’t really a part of the games – the immunity token. This was introduced only in Season 2 and was not used in the following seasons, which allowed the owner to skip a Death Match. A good amount of play time during Episodes 3 to 5 were spent on players who have clues on the whereabouts of the immunity token looking for it, so they weren’t able to focus on the Main Matches.
Moreover, thing went awry in Episode 6 when Jiwon took the ID of contestant Dohee (known for hacking Seoul National University’s website), which was an important element of playing the Main Match of that episode. As a result of looking for it until the last round, Dohee wasn’t able to properly participate in the game and was automatically sent to the Death Match. Things became more uncomfortable to watch when Sangmin gave him a fake immunity token, which he used, only to find out that he was duped for the second time in one episode. For a show that stated right from the start of Season 1 that “violence or theft is not allowed,” it was very disappointing how the producers did not step in and forced Jiwon to surrender Dohee’s ID.
Season 3 had a very different player dynamic from the past two seasons because of the backlash the show received with the Episode 6 mess and the alliance among celebrities and non-celebrities. Thus, the third season had more “normal” and “regular” people as contestants. The alliance between Hyunmin and Dongmin pretty much ruled the entire season, but what was great about it was the two did not make their relationship too obvious and still allowed the other players to display brilliant gameplay, especially Yeonseung who considered himself an outsider the entire season, yet managed to be part of the final 3. The games themselves were not as dynamic as the first two seasons, but we were allowed to see the vulnerabilities in all the players.
Sadly, The Genius is not streaming on any platform, although subtitled episodes have been available on YouTube and Dailymotion. International diehard fans have also made it something of a cult classic, with reddit and Discord forums still alive six years after the last episode was aired. It can be said that the show’s popularity can be narrowed down to three factors: The novel but interesting concept, the genius-level editing of the show’s episode (the fast forward and flashback scenes get people to anticipate what’s happening and why things turn out they way they eventually did), and finally, the relatability of the contestants who really made sure they played the games to the best of their abilities, which made the show all the more watchable. Hopefully, we can get tVN to release the show’s four seasons in a streaming platform for more audiences to experience it.
Featured Image: Screengrab from Tvn Youtube Channel “The Genius Game” trailer